Pressure treated vs. Dip Treatment

Slow Grown Spruce Dunster House

I’ll be honest. Before I came to work at Dunster House, I didn’t have a clue about Pressure Treatment, dip treatment or treatment of any kind. Of course, I had heard of the importance of treating your shed but not enough to make any informed decision. This initial naivety puts me in a prime position to explain the differences using as little technical ‘jargon’ as I can.

How does it work?

Pressure Treated

Treatment is forced into the timber once it is sealed in this chamber

Pressure Treated

Image from BuySheds Direct shows the basic idea around dip treating

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The process of Pressure Treatment is quite simple. We take the timber, after it has been cut to size, and place it on a pallet. The wood is then placed into a large circular tank which is underground and is sealed before the air is removed via vacuum. By removing the moisture within the timber, we are left with more space deep within the timber. After the air has been removed, the tank is flooded with our preservative (Tanalith ‘E’ Tanatone). Once the tank is full, the air is removed again which forces the preservative deep into the grain of the wood. Normally, the timber will come out a faint green colour but we have a brown additive added to make it come out a rich brown colour. By pre cutting the timber, we ensure that you are provided with fully treated pieces of timber rather than exposed ends.

 

Dip treatment, sometimes called dipping, is different. As with the Pressure Treatment process, there is a tank underground. However instead of the timber being sealed within a deep chamber, the timber was simply immersed in a bath of treatment for a period of time. These are then left to dry.  In ‘The Preservative Treatment of Farm Timbers’, George McMonies Hunt explains that dip treatment “allows all checks and defects to become filled (…), but the penetration and absorption are usually slight”[1]

Level of protection provided?

The way in which I interpret dip treatment is that it is a fake tan for timber. It does make your product look good by adding a colour to the timber, but this may thin or fade overtime, but this is just a temporary solution and does not truly protect your building. You may be reading this shaking your head in disagreement, having owned a dip treated Log Cabin, and think it has worked perfectly well. However if you have followed the rules by reapplying treatment annually then that is your protection, not the dip treatment itself.

Pressure treatment commonly arrives to you kiln or air dried. The treatment is so deeply enthused into the grain of the timber that reapplication is rarely needed. Pressure treated products have, by far, more protection against rot and fungal decay.

Cost difference?

Dip treated timber is initially cheaper to purchase than pressure treated timber. This is due to the dip treating process taking less time and therefore incurring lower labour and storage costs. However, with dip treatment, you will need to retreat your Garden Building annually with some companies stating that you need to treat this when before construction as well. A decent timber treatment can cost £20-£50. If you have to purchase treatment yearly, the costs soon add up.

When you purchase a Pressure Treated Garden Building, the pressure treatment is deep within the timber and then dried naturally using either air (if it is hot outside) or, like us, a kiln drier. The timber is then protected for a number of years, in our case 10 years which we guarantee, against rot and fungal decay. The process requires a lot of time, effort and storage meaning that the initial cost of your product may be higher but will save you both time and money.

Convenience?

By far, Pressure Treated timber is more convenient than dip treated or untreated timber. If you order dip treated timber, you don’t need to conduct any additional treatment before constructing or for a length of time afterwards. If you purchase dip treated timber you often have to reapply treatment before construction and then annually. This may not seem like a lot, but the reapplication of timber will mean deconstructing and reconstructing your cabin each year. We conducted an experiment with our Playsystem to see how long it would take to retreat it and found it can take up to three days. That is three days per year that you lose to treatment.

As you can see from the comparisons above, Pressure Treated timber is the best option for your Garden Building.  Think of it like buying your first car. Sure, you could purchase a second hand car off of Gumtree for a relatively small price (dip treated cabin) rather than from a second hand car dealership (Pressure Treated Cabin). You will save money initially but the costs of the MOT (retreatment) will soon have you regretting your lack of investment.

Please note: You should always be careful when looking at any Guarantees offered on untreated timber and read the fine print as you will often find they are pointless. As always, feel free to ask me any questions.

 

[1] Hunt, G. Mcmonies (1928) The Preservative Treatment of Farm Timbers, p24

May 20, 2015

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *